The Cape Peninsula dangles off the underside of Africa like a tough fishhook, curling spherical from the frigid waters of the Atlantic Coast into the broad expanse of False Bay.
This island-like geography has created a plethora of waves, from spitting seashore breaks and big-wave reefs to the learners’ paradise of Muizenberg. Regardless of the abundance of setups, the peninsula is way extra well-known for its different marine sights.
For the reason that early 2000s, False Bay has turn out to be a world-renowned location for cage diving with nice white sharks or to witness the spectacular breaching phenomenon—the place these sharks launch themselves into the air whereas looking seals. Much less spectacular is encountering considered one of these leviathans whereas browsing, which additionally turned a much more frequent incidence on the flip of the millennium.
Between 2010 and 2016, there have been 205 nice white shark sightings on common per yr recorded by the Shark Spotters, an organization set up specifically to monitor shark activity around the peninsula. Varied scientific research estimated there have been, extra precisely, between 300-to-500 nice white sharks contained in the bay, making it dwelling to one of many densest concentrations of white sharks on this planet.
As a surfer who’d grown up in these waters, I couldn’t assist however really feel barely unsettled by statistics like this whereas investigating a narrative about Cape City’s shark phenomenon in 2015. However I additionally took solace in the truth that it was absolutely a sign of a wholesome ecosystem. Nice whites have been protected in South African waters since 1991, and False Bay was teeming with life—not simply nice whites, however an abundance of different shark, fish and marine species.
Then in 2017, the variety of nice white sightings recorded by the Shark Spotters plummeted to 57. In 2018, this determine dropped additional to simply 50. By 2019, there have been zero recorded sightings, mirrored by a whole absence of white sharks in cage diving encounters. Within the house of three years, Cape Town’s apex predators had actually disappeared.
“What we now have seen in simply the previous few years has been nothing wanting a calamitous crash of our nice white shark inhabitants alongside the south and southwest Cape shoreline,” says Chris Fallows, a world-renowned cage diving operator and wildlife photographer primarily based in False Bay.
Whereas the considered fewer white sharks may make native surfers’ toes curl much less within the lineup, the ecological implications could possibly be dire. It’s well-known that sharks play a significant position in sustaining a steadiness within the ocean ecosystem and their disappearance, says Fallows, could have catastrophic outcomes.
It was initially speculated that the culprits could possibly be a pair of orcas nicknamed Port and Starboard, who had been first noticed in False Bay in early 2015. Orcas are the one species identified to predate on nice whites and different massive sharks. They typically hunt in pairs, attacking the pectoral fins and ripping the shark open to eat its liver, which is wealthy in fats.
Between 2015 and 2017, plenty of sevengill and nice white sharks washed up on shore with these telltale wounds in False Bay and Gansbaai, one other nice white shark hotspot additional east.
Dr. Alison Kock, a number one shark scientist and marine biologist, theorized that a new sub-group of killer whale that specifically targets sharks could have moved closer to shore as their offshore meals sources declined, altering the construction of the False Bay meals chain. As these new apex predators appeared extra often within the bay, the nice whites had fled.
Fallows, nevertheless, is skeptical that killer whales are solely accountable.
“Throughout all encounters with orcas in False Bay and round Seal Island, we by no means seen a drop off in sightings of nice whites,” he says, citing in depth units of information that tracks the presence of orcas in False Bay since 2009. “I’m not saying that orca predation doesn’t or has not had an impact on white shark residency… (however) these results are brief to medium time period, as mirrored in different places all over the world the place orca predation on nice whites has truly been witnessed.”
Quite, Fallows believes it’s the disappearance of smaller sharks that has had a ripple impact all the best way up the meals chain.
“Within the late 1990s, South African fisheries scientists gave out demersal shark longline permits,” explains Fallows. “This (kind of fishing) permits a number of thousand hooks to be set on the ocean flooring to focus on smaller sharks.”
Particularly, smooth-hound sharks and soupfin sharks, which congregate in dense shoals and had been traditionally plentiful in False Bay.
Based on Fallows, it’s a typical false impression that South African nice whites feed primarily on seals. Quite, smaller shark species and bony fish are their main meals supply, making up 60 % of their weight loss program. These sharks had been fished intermittently round False Bay at first, largely to complement different catches, till 2015.
“All of a sudden, three demersal shark longline allow holders actually began fishing the useful resource arduous,” says Fallows. “They realized how, the place and when to focus on the smooth-hound and soupfin sharks. Their catches soared as might be seen by the export knowledge to Australia, the place the sharks are bought for fish and chips. For the nice white, this has been nothing wanting a demise blow.”
Sometimes called “flake” in Australia, smooth-hound shark is often utilized in Australian fish and chips. Many customers don’t even know they’re consuming shark—in keeping with Australian seafood labeling legal guidelines, solely contemporary and frozen fish must be recognized. As soon as it’s cooked, there isn’t a authorized obligation to call the species and shark is named all the pieces from “flake” to “pearled fillet”, “boneless fillet” and even “monkfish”.
Australia has its personal smooth-hound shark fishing business however it’s sustainably managed with strict quotas and enforcement. With a purpose to meet the massive extra demand for fish and chips, importers merely began bringing in shark from South Africa,
where the fishery is poorly managed with little regulation.
“For Australia, it’s a double win,” says Fallows. “They’re defending their useful resource from overfishing by having effectively researched and well-enforced quotas. To make up the demand deficit, they import our sharks at a good alternate fee. The injury being carried out on the opposite facet of the ocean is unknown to most individuals in Australia, who’re unwittingly consuming our sharks of their fish and chips.”
In contrast to in Australia, there isn’t a restrict on the entire allowable catch in South Africa. Since 2011, the Division of Surroundings, Forestry and Fisheries’ (DEFF) personal scientists have said that these sharks are being harvested at an unsustainable fee—virtually thrice the annual really useful quota—and have made pressing suggestions to restrict the entire allowable catch, however this has been repeatedly ignored by administration and coverage makers. To make issues worse, shark longliners have been documented fishing inside South Africa’s flagship marine reserves—the equal of longline fishing on the Nice Barrier Reef. In 2019, DEFF scientists warned that smooth-hound and soupfin shark populations had been in a state of collapse.
Repeated makes an attempt to get a remark from the Division went unanswered, however the science additionally echoes anecdotal proof I had heard whereas speaking to native surfer Pierre de Villiers again in 2015.
De Villiers isn’t a scientist. His credentials have been earned by many years of browsing and diving the Cape reefs. Together with Peter Button, he pioneered Dungeons lengthy earlier than there have been boats with photographers that dropped you within the lineup. Again then your solely choice was to lug your rhino chaser across the towering Sentinel mountain and make the 200-meter paddle out by Shark Alley, a deep channel flanked on both facet by a rocky seal colony the place it was jokingly mentioned that white sharks would hang around like prospects at a drive-through.
A champion spearfisherman, De Villiers advised me how, up till the early 2000s, the peninsula was teeming with smooth-hound sharks.
“They used to come back round Cape Level and into the bay in numbers that had been mindboggling. You’d swim over and also you’d see a mass of gray issues beneath you. They give the impression of being… scary till you understand they’ll’t chunk you. However there have been thousands and thousands of them. Guys used to get extra money for them than yellowtail… In order that they fished these sharks till they disappeared.”
Historic and present knowledge bears out De Villiers’ long-held observations. Between 2014 and 2018, the entire quantity of shark merchandise exported from South Africa to Australia rocketed from round 8,000 kilograms per yr to just about 60,000 kilograms in keeping with TRAFFIC, the wildlife commerce monitoring community. The variety of smooth-hound sharks killed by demersal longline fishing in 2018 alone was a staggering 30,112—all exported to Australia.
Fallows, and different consultants in South Africa and Australia, at the moment are focusing their efforts on elevating consciousness across the concern and attempting to teach finish customers in regards to the devastating impression the fishery is having by a marketing campaign referred to as Shark Free Chips—earlier than it’s too late.
“It’s not stunning that the nice whites have gone and can proceed to vanish additional up the coast as their main meals supply is fished to nothing,” says Fallows. “In simply 4 brief years we now have seen large ecological adjustments which will by no means be capable to be rectified, sadly all for fish and chips.”
This text initially appeared on Surfer.com and was republished with permission.
For entry to unique gear movies, superstar interviews, and extra, subscribe on YouTube!